Ok. It seems like I have three options.
1. Used Second Gen starter off Ebay will cost about $120 delivered.
2. The Rick's Motorsports Premium Starter is about $220, 1 year warranty
3. What looks like the way to go - Several different brand labels on what appears to actually be the same starter, a Mitsuba, from $160 to $170, all with a 1 year warranty.
An extra $40 for new with warranty seems a no-brainer. Ricks appears to have a shinier case, but nothing stating what technically makes thier's better.
Has anybody used this "mitsuba"?????
Edit - more searching, Mitsuba is Japanese, not Chinese. Maybe they are the original supplier anyway?