I had the one SQUIDLY has on my 1st gen and really liked it.
I tried some of the others on my 2nd gen and they don't last very long.
The vibration and weight of a 12oz bottle seems to break the plastic at the swivel or it cracks and breaks where it bolts up.
The one I have now I picked up in STURGIS this last Aug cause I needed something to hold my water bottle.
I should of gone back to what works (like the one SQUIDLY has).
It is inexpensive and works well.
When the one I have now breaks, I will head to Wal-Mart again..............Ron