To each his own.
As much as us Gen 1, and 2 folks wanted a bike with a radiator, that wasn't so hot at the stoplights, I'll admit, I saw a few kinda nasty posts.
But, also, find someone that bought a 3rd Gen, dropped 25k plus, and is willing to say they regret it. Although they might ALL very much like them, and I certainly would like to own one, I just don't ride enough to justify it.
I think it is too early in the process to get true results as into if the 1st time buyers, buy again.
But, back to the 2nd gen. If you like it, why would you want to change?